Welcome,Flow Switches,Shanghai ZanKe Automation Technology Co., Ltd Hotline:18001874240
Language:
∷
∷
∷
Comparison Between Thermal Flow Switches and Piston Flow Switches in Accuracy
1. Accuracy of Thermal Flow Switches
High Precision: Typically achieves ±0.5% to ±2% of full-scale accuracy, with some models capable of detecting flows as low as 0.1 L/min.
No Mechanical Wear: Relies on thermal diffusion principles, ensuring long-term stability without degradation from moving parts.
Fast Response: Electronic signal processing enables millisecond-level reaction time, ideal for dynamic flow control.
Case Example:
Semiconductor Cooling System: A thermal flow switch (Model NK-200) was used to monitor ultra-precise coolant flow in a 5 L/min system, maintaining ±1% accuracy over three years without recalibration.
2. Accuracy of Piston Flow Switches
Moderate Precision: Generally ±5% of full-scale, with repeatability affected by mechanical friction and fluid viscosity.
Mechanical Limitations: Piston movement introduces inherent delays, and accuracy may decline with wear over time.
Viscosity Sensitivity: Performance varies with fluid properties; high-viscosity fluids can cause ±10% deviation.
Case Example:
Industrial Hydraulic System: A piston flow switch in a 20 L/min oil circulation system showed ±7% accuracy initially but required annual recalibration due to piston wear.
3. Comprehensive Comparison
Parameter Thermal Flow Switch Piston Flow Switch
Accuracy ±0.5% to ±2% ±5% (±10% for high-viscosity fluids)
Response Time Milliseconds Slower (mechanical delay)
Long-Term Stability High (no wear) Moderate (requires maintenance)
4. Selection Recommendations
Choose Thermal Flow Switches for:
Critical applications requiring high precision (e.g., pharmaceutical dosing, laboratory equipment).
Low-flow detection (e.g., <1 L/min in microfluidic systems).
Choose Piston Flow Switches for:
Cost-sensitive projects where ±5% accuracy is acceptable (e.g., irrigation systems, general industrial monitoring).
High-viscosity or dirty fluids where thermal sensors may fail.
Case Example:
Medical Infusion Pump: A thermal flow switch ensured ±0.8% accuracy in a 0.5 mL/min drug delivery system, while a piston switch would have exceeded acceptable error margins.
Conclusion
Thermal flow switches outperform piston types in accuracy due to their electronic precision and wear-free design. However, piston switches remain viable for less critical applications where mechanical robustness outweighs precision requirements.
新闻资讯
